Results 1 to 20 of 20

Thread: DIY: Window Regulator (Advanced)

  1. #1
    nathancarter is offline Stretch Haters Club #1 BMW CCA Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Tampa, FL
    Posts
    11,328
    My Cars
    2002 330i 131k

    DIY: Window Regulator (Advanced)

    This is for my 2002 330i sedan. It is probably applicable to many similar models.

    This DIY assumes the following:
    1. You already know how to access and remove the window regulators (E46 Window Regulator)
    2. You're pretty mechanically inclined and have a reasonable tool kit
    3. You're a cheapskate like me, and don't want to buy a new regulator if the old one is repairable.

    When both my front windows died on me, I figured I would open them up, pop on a couple zip ties, and be on my way. However, I found damage beyond what could be repaired in the "usual" manner. Not wanting to shell out $150-200 for two new regulators, I attempted to repair them.

    Part 1: The Knob & Cradle (because I don't know what else to call them)


    The Knob must sit securely in the Cradle. If it's not broken, the Cradle has a plastic tab that holds onto the cable, thereby keeping the Knob in place. However, the cable is always pressing against that tab, and eventually will break it off, allowing the knob to roam free. Note that this is the usual failure mode for these window regulators, and if this is your only problem, it can probably be repaired with just zip ties.

    DON'T OVER-TIGHTEN THE ZIP TIES or they will break once you start reassembling and operating the window (ask how I know).



    I cleaned the parts thoroughly using brake cleaner. I then used a combination of zip ties and Gorilla Glue to make sure that Knob ain't goin' nowhere:



    Gorilla Glue requires a bit of water to activate. After it is activated, it will foam up a bit after several minutes. So DON'T USE TOO MUCH! I swabbed out a bit of this with a Q-tip.






    Part 2: Broken pulleys
    The regulator cable glides along a rounded nylon/plastic "pulley". It's not really a pulley since it doesn't rotate, but it effectively works the same, so I'll call it a pulley until someone corrects me.

    The forces of the regulator and springs and motor are always attempting to twist this pulley out of its correct position, and only two flimsy plastic nubs hold it in place. Eventually, they will break. I think this is exacerbated by the Knob coming loose from the Cradle, or perhaps vice-versa.



    There's no way to repair the plastic. But I used something better: Metal.
    I used some wood screws to replace the plastic nubs. But, you can't just screw the wood screws into the plastic pulley, you must drill a pilot hole first.
    As previously mentioned, there's a lot of force trying to rotate the pulley. So, I used a vise to hold the pulley in the correct position while I drilled the first pilot hole and screwed in the screw. I could not drill the second pilot hole while it was in the vise, since the vise was in the way of my drill chuck.


    Screw in the screw, remove from vise, drill second pilot hole, and screw in the second screw. DON'T over-tighten or you'll strip the plastic.



    I also chose to reinforce the plastic nubs on the other side of the regulator. They weren't broken YET, but I didn't want to do this again.



    This left an unpleasant problem on the back side of the pulley:



    I used a bench grinder to grind them flush with the surface of the pulley:




    Done!
    Wipe down the rails on which the mechanism slides and re-lubricate with a very thin application of grease, then re-install.

    This repair has worked for several weeks on my driver's window, which I now use nearly every day. It's fast and quiet.

    Unfortunately, it didn't last long on the front passenger window. I haven't yet disassembled it to find out why, but I'll update this post after I do. (buying a new regulator for passenger side).

    After going over my photos, I think the pulley wasn't in the exactly right place when I drilled the pilot hole; if you look at the last photo, the cable doesn't exactly line up with the scuffed line on the paint where the cable SHOULD be. I should have rotated the pulley a bit more before drilling the pilot hole.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Memphis
    Posts
    251
    My Cars
    2001 330i Titanium Silver
    very interesting writeup! Thanks.

    You would think the brilliant engineers would just develop a regulator without these issues.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    Maryland
    Posts
    1,113
    My Cars
    2008 128i
    A regulator without those issues would either break the glass regularly or impale the occupants during a side collision.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    Ohio
    Posts
    96
    My Cars
    323I
    Yeah, BMW stealerships would come up with something to get you to buy the sub standard crap that they push onto the owners so they can keep breaking stuff and making money...

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Willimantic CT
    Posts
    25
    My Cars
    2002 330i
    Thats good to know i just bought my car today and knew this car was infamous for this problem so i tried all the windows.... sure enough one broke so i get to bring my new car back already!!! woohoo!!!

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Honolulu
    Posts
    45
    My Cars
    2002 325i
    Damnit, your about 20 hrs late with this post i just did mine after reading every thread on this forum about it and this would have been EXTREMELY helpful, i did not even know what a regulator was i just followed a diy but it lacked in the actual fixing. Good post

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Greenville, SC, USA
    Posts
    247
    My Cars
    1999 BMW 323i
    i shall get started on my car tonight!!!!!!!!!! wish me luck!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  8. #8
    nathancarter is offline Stretch Haters Club #1 BMW CCA Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Tampa, FL
    Posts
    11,328
    My Cars
    2002 330i 131k
    As I previously noted, this fix didn't last long on my front passenger side. The cradle was just too badly damaged and the glue didn't hold, and the zip ties couldn't keep the cable from sliding up and down, and were cut apart by the cable.

    So, I bought a replacement regulator for the front passenger side and reinforced it with the zip ties and screws as shown above.

    My repaired driver's window is still smooth and quiet, though it's a little bit slower than the other three windows.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Toronto
    Posts
    27
    My Cars
    2002 BMW 325i

    Thumbs up ZIP Tie

    The zip tie fix works very well. Had it on my car for 4 months now. No problem.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    13,674
    My Cars
    2005 325Xi
    Quote Originally Posted by Mad Dragon View Post
    A regulator without those issues would either break the glass regularly or impale the occupants during a side collision.

    I don't think that metal inserts for the pulleys and a more secure "knob" in the "cradle" would be implaing anyone.

    It's simply a matter of economics. BMW bean-counters have figured out that it's cheaper to have these regulators manufactured with plastic pulleys and no reinforcement for the "knob" and to replace the ones that fail under warranty, than it is to just have them all manufactured stronger to begin with.
    Quote Originally Posted by B4SH View Post
    If anyone knows, it's this guy who knows literally nothing about everything.
    Quote Originally Posted by fcvapor05 View Post
    Do you even OT? The mean 401k around here is probably about $6, what with all the shiny cars and $1,000 watches and donations to get other members' Volvos running.


  11. #11
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Killen, AL
    Posts
    91
    My Cars
    '98 Z3, '00 323I
    I think i will use JB Weld instead of gorilla glue..it hardes like steel. have used on cracked blocks...thoughts?

  12. #12
    nathancarter is offline Stretch Haters Club #1 BMW CCA Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Location
    Tampa, FL
    Posts
    11,328
    My Cars
    2002 330i 131k
    JB Weld should work just fine. Whatever it takes to make sure the sliding metal bracket stays attached to the cable.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Killen, AL
    Posts
    91
    My Cars
    '98 Z3, '00 323I
    all fixed...went with the gorilla glue no issues thanks

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    dfw texas
    Posts
    103
    My Cars
    1988 535i, 2001 325ci
    Ja, wir bauen besten Autos auf dem Planeten. so gut, wir etwas brechen müssen daher können wir mehr Geld
    translate to english you silly americans,

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    FV, CA
    Posts
    56
    My Cars
    BMW 03' 325i
    great writing op. You may want to put DIY Front window regulator: Advanced instead otherwise it is a bit confusing.

  16. #16
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    maui
    Posts
    1
    My Cars
    BMW 325i
    What if the window in my BMW 325i is stuck and doesnt want to come down? is there a way i can bring down manually?

  17. #17
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    San Clemente, CA
    Posts
    4
    My Cars
    325
    Thanks for the write-up and the many success stories of fixing the front window of a E46. If window is open 2-4" from the top of the door, you'll be able to slide the glass 1/4" with your hands. I suspect a failure mode may likely be the mechanical interface between the "knob" and "cradle". I'll tackle this project next weekend. Thanks again.

  18. #18
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    olmsted falls, ohio
    Posts
    16
    My Cars
    2000 bmw 323i

    Re: window regulator

    Quote Originally Posted by nathancarter View Post
    This is for my 2002 330i sedan. It is probably applicable to many similar models.

    This DIY assumes the following:
    1. You already know how to access and remove the window regulators (E46 Window Regulator)
    2. You're pretty mechanically inclined and have a reasonable tool kit
    3. You're a cheapskate like me, and don't want to buy a new regulator if the old one is repairable.

    When both my front windows died on me, I figured I would open them up, pop on a couple zip ties, and be on my way. However, I found damage beyond what could be repaired in the "usual" manner. Not wanting to shell out $150-200 for two new regulators, I attempted to repair them.

    Part 1: The Knob & Cradle (because I don't know what else to call them)


    The Knob must sit securely in the Cradle. If it's not broken, the Cradle has a plastic tab that holds onto the cable, thereby keeping the Knob in place. However, the cable is always pressing against that tab, and eventually will break it off, allowing the knob to roam free. Note that this is the usual failure mode for these window regulators, and if this is your only problem, it can probably be repaired with just zip ties.

    DON'T OVER-TIGHTEN THE ZIP TIES or they will break once you start reassembling and operating the window (ask how I know).



    I cleaned the parts thoroughly using brake cleaner. I then used a combination of zip ties and Gorilla Glue to make sure that Knob ain't goin' nowhere:



    Gorilla Glue requires a bit of water to activate. After it is activated, it will foam up a bit after several minutes. So DON'T USE TOO MUCH! I swabbed out a bit of this with a Q-tip.






    Part 2: Broken pulleys
    The regulator cable glides along a rounded nylon/plastic "pulley". It's not really a pulley since it doesn't rotate, but it effectively works the same, so I'll call it a pulley until someone corrects me.

    The forces of the regulator and springs and motor are always attempting to twist this pulley out of its correct position, and only two flimsy plastic nubs hold it in place. Eventually, they will break. I think this is exacerbated by the Knob coming loose from the Cradle, or perhaps vice-versa.



    There's no way to repair the plastic. But I used something better: Metal.
    I used some wood screws to replace the plastic nubs. But, you can't just screw the wood screws into the plastic pulley, you must drill a pilot hole first.
    As previously mentioned, there's a lot of force trying to rotate the pulley. So, I used a vise to hold the pulley in the correct position while I drilled the first pilot hole and screwed in the screw. I could not drill the second pilot hole while it was in the vise, since the vise was in the way of my drill chuck.


    Screw in the screw, remove from vise, drill second pilot hole, and screw in the second screw. DON'T over-tighten or you'll strip the plastic.



    I also chose to reinforce the plastic nubs on the other side of the regulator. They weren't broken YET, but I didn't want to do this again.



    This left an unpleasant problem on the back side of the pulley:



    I used a bench grinder to grind them flush with the surface of the pulley:




    Done!
    Wipe down the rails on which the mechanism slides and re-lubricate with a very thin application of grease, then re-install.

    This repair has worked for several weeks on my driver's window, which I now use nearly every day. It's fast and quiet.

    Unfortunately, it didn't last long on the front passenger window. I haven't yet disassembled it to find out why, but I'll update this post after I do. (buying a new regulator for passenger side).

    After going over my photos, I think the pulley wasn't in the exactly right place when I drilled the pilot hole; if you look at the last photo, the cable doesn't exactly line up with the scuffed line on the paint where the cable SHOULD be. I should have rotated the pulley a bit more before drilling the pilot hole.
    FYI: my rear driver window regulator went kaput. picked one up at advanced auto for 43 bux.(they matched an online price) manufactured by dorman which is a reputable company from ohio. installed in 45 min.

  19. #19
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Chicago
    Posts
    49
    My Cars
    99 E46 Sed.
    It seems like it's a lot of work to repair it. This is one part i did not get from the dealer when my driver side one went bad. I got mine from napa for 60 bucks.

    Sent from my iPad using BF.com

  20. #20
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Location
    Worcester, MA
    Posts
    1,689
    My Cars
    03 540i Msport Touring
    time for some biblical necroposting (three+ years later) to check and see if this has worked long term for anyone?
    also, are the e39 and e46 window regulators very similar.
    Looking for an e39 Touring black carpet set, including the rear cargo cubbies and side sections!
    ALSO looking for 540i 6speed manual transmission sets (2001+ pedals with switches, driveshaft, gearbox), for the 6speed swap! Probably not for a while....

    GN92489
    540i msport touring; jet black on grey
    Progress Thread (general)
    Progress thread (touring specific)


Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •