View Full Version : My 99 M3 VS Modded 01 S4


NC98///M3
10-05-2005, 05:52 PM
This happend a few weeks back...just been too lazy to post it up.
I was back home and driving down one of the main roads. I saw a black B5 S4 sitting at a light, he pulled out of the light to follow me. Once we got a little farther ahead we both took a left from a stop sign, I punched up and he kept right up with me and I head a bov/diverter valve. It was then I knew it wasn't stock. I had him pull over and we chatted for a bit. His car 2001 S4 6 speed: Revo Tecknic chip, some kind of CAI (not a pannel filter), removal of mid-cats and replaced with straight pipes, diverter valve, ssk. We decided first to go from a 40 roll.

1st race: 40 roll 2nd gear- door to door up to 100ish when we let off.
2nd roll: 3rd gear 60-70ish roll up to 140- He slowly pulls just under 1/2 a car.
3rd roll: 3rd gear 75 roll up to 135- He pulls 1/4 of a car.

He was a very good driver, so I was expecting to get my ass handed to me. I know just a chipped S4 makes in the range of 320hp. Not to mention all this mods. He estimated around the 340-350 crank hp range. He had a 1/4 tank of gas, so did I. Neither of us had passengers. Good races overall. Anyone else had any experiences with chiped S4's? I know they are SUPPOSTO be faster than bolt-on E36 M3's, so please don't preach to me about getting my butt handed to me.

VandyS4
10-05-2005, 06:46 PM
Is your M3 stock?

On paper, he should've won by more. I pulled harder than that on a 98 M3 with my chip and stock DPs. Could be a boost leak, could be he lied, could be bad software, could be a bad driver. Anything can happen on the street.

Then again, if his car is running right, and you managed to keep up, then...that's very impressive :D

giterdone
10-05-2005, 07:00 PM
Is your M3 stock?

On paper, he should've won by more. I pulled harder than that on a 98 M3 with my chip and stock DPs. Could be a boost leak, could be he lied, could be bad software, could be a bad driver. Anything can happen on the street.

Then again, if his car is running right, and you managed to keep up, then...that's very impressive :D
pretty much what Vandy said. I haven't raced an S4, but from what all I've heard, and read, he should've definately had you by alot more. I believe it is supposed to be a drivers race stock for stock, since he had all that, yeck, good race :thumbup:

NC98///M3
10-05-2005, 09:24 PM
He was a very good driver, so I was expecting to get my ass handed to me. I know just a chipped S4 makes in the range of 320hp. Not to mention all this mods. He estimated around the 340-350 crank hp range. He had a 1/4 tank of gas, so did I. Neither of us had passengers. Good races overall. Anyone else had any experiences with chiped S4's? I know they are SUPPOSED TO be faster than bolt-on E36 M3's, so please don't preach to me about getting my butt handed to me.

I know he should have beaten me. Oh the car was running very strong. It only had like 15K miles on it. He said it was running very strong. Thanks for the kind words guys. I know a stock S4 and stock M3 is a drivers race. I almost bought a B5 S4. But my car's not stock (it's close to stock).

a4rings
10-05-2005, 09:28 PM
you must be a VERY good driver, if some other guy with a close to stock e36 m3 posted this i would laugh at him but it seems that your purple people eater just runns really strong and i saw that video of you racing the 300+whp cobra. So good race man.

giterdone
10-05-2005, 09:42 PM
I know he should have beaten me. Oh the car was running very strong. It only had like 15K miles on it. He said it was running very strong. Thanks for the kind words guys. I know a stock S4 and stock M3 is a drivers race. I almost bought a B5 S4. But my car's not stock (it's close to stock).
haha yeah, I know you said don't preach to ya, I wasn't badgering you about it. Just stating, don't worry, unlike some my reading comprehension is normally pretty good. :D

Love4540
10-05-2005, 10:08 PM
S4's are mean cars...from a dig. Up top the awd kills them. From a stop is when you would notice it because he would launch cl's in front with an awd launch, and his boost would have been more apparent as well. Nice run none the less.

Schneller Bayer
10-05-2005, 10:17 PM
Stock for stock the m has a bit of an edge, but this modded b5 should have put some car lengths on you. Good job on your part, and your car's to keep up though.

mmart6545
10-05-2005, 10:22 PM
So you hang with E46 m3s?

VandyS4
10-06-2005, 02:17 AM
So you hang with E46 m3s?

Are you setting up for another e-steroid rage?

DefactoM6
10-06-2005, 05:30 PM
Isn't NC's car S/Ced? In which case he should've handed it to the S4....

a4rings
10-06-2005, 06:28 PM
not its not supercharged, its close to stock.

redfoot
10-06-2005, 11:24 PM
Is your M3 stock?

On paper, he should've won by more. I pulled harder than that on a 98 M3 with my chip and stock DPs. Could be a boost leak, could be he lied, could be bad software, could be a bad driver. Anything can happen on the street.

Then again, if his car is running right, and you managed to keep up, then...that's very impressive :D
Hate to say it......
+1 for the lie.

redfoot
10-07-2005, 09:12 AM
:lol ok mr I joined in 2005.... i'm a big fat liar...:rolleyes
Ok, Mr. I Have No Reading Comprehention,
I wasn't calling you a liar but the person with the S4 and claimed to have mods that put him well over 300whp.
Ease-up!:confused

NC98///M3
10-07-2005, 09:45 PM
300whp? Yeah, right. B5 S4's only dyno low 200's. No way he had 300hp. We'll I rode in his car, saw his boost gauge, saw the intake, looked under the car at the straight pipes. He couldn't be lying. No, he wasn't a crappy driver. I edited my presumtion, i'm sorry.

redfoot
10-07-2005, 10:01 PM
300whp? Yeah, right. B5 S4's only dyno low 200's. No way he had 300hp. We'll I rode in his car, saw his boost gauge, saw the intake, looked under the car at the straight pipes. He couldn't be lying. No, he wasn't a crappy driver. I edited my presumtion, i'm sorry.
My bad on the errant "w" while quoting hp for the S. He should have close to 300 at crank...................

Ya know what, who cares anyway?

NC98///M3
10-08-2005, 12:53 AM
NP man. He probally put down 250whp-270whp. But it's over 300 to the crank. APR is very conservative with their tunning, and a apr chip puts the B5 S4 at about 310 crank (60hp) Revo get about 75hp with their chip. I'm getting ready to buy an 2002 B5 S4 it looks like. :devillook If I can give up my baby.

a4rings
10-08-2005, 02:46 AM
hey is definitely making more the 250 whp, i would say 270+
assuming he actually has the mds he says he does

SantoringS4
10-08-2005, 06:09 PM
he SHOULD be around 280whp and 310-330 wtrq. Chip, intake, and turbo back exhaust in a 6spd should be able to beat E46 M3's quiet easily if the driver can drive. So I'm guessing either you're faster than an e46 m3 OR he didn't know how to drive.

m3racer36
10-08-2005, 07:53 PM
Good story

VandyS4
10-08-2005, 08:17 PM
he SHOULD be around 280whp and 310-330 wtrq. Chip, intake, and turbo back exhaust in a 6spd should be able to beat E46 M3's quiet easily if the driver can drive.

I wouldn't say easily, but he'd pull away.

SantoringS4
10-09-2005, 01:12 AM
I wouldn't say easily, but he'd pull away.


My tip with catback pulls slowly on e46 m3s, and 6spd stage 2s without downpipes put a car and a half on me from a dig.

VandyS4
10-09-2005, 01:45 AM
My tip with catback pulls slowly on e46 m3s, and 6spd stage 2s without downpipes put a car and a half on me from a dig.

X-sauce in all cases, I'm assuming?

NC98///M3
10-09-2005, 02:58 AM
I wouldn't say easily, but he'd pull away.

well I DID say he pulled away. Is that sarcasm dane?

m3racer36
10-09-2005, 03:10 AM
nah def not, they are pigs as far as weight goes. If the drivr hesitated at all I could see this happening. I drove one with close to the same mods and I wasnt impressed. My workout partner has one to with the same mods also.

Schneller Bayer
10-09-2005, 05:37 AM
Well, an s4 modded like the one you raced, does have nearly 300whp capabilities. However, a 280 whp s4 shouldn't pull a stock e46 m3, unless it was from a dig. AWD isn't going to help it on the highway, PLUS the car is actually heavier than the e46 m.

VandyS4
10-09-2005, 04:04 PM
well I DID say he pulled away. Is that sarcasm dane?

Dane?

And no, it wasn't sarcasm.

a4rings
10-09-2005, 04:23 PM
Well, an s4 modded like the one you raced, does have nearly 300whp capabilities. However, a 280 whp s4 shouldn't pull a stock e46 m3, unless it was from a dig. AWD isn't going to help it on the highway, PLUS the car is actually heavier than the e46 m.

I can see what you are arguing about a 280whp s4 not pulling onan e46 m3 but also compare the torque of the two cars. An s4with 280whp has more then 280wtq, and i know that an e46 m3 has nowhere near the same torque, also how is AWD going to hurt the s4 on the highway if it already has 280whp, awd isnt going to take away extra power just because they are on the highway now.

m3racer36
10-09-2005, 10:14 PM
Vandys4 is your name dane to? Im pretty sure he was talking to me

VandyS4
10-10-2005, 12:59 AM
Vandys4 is your name dane to? Im pretty sure he was talking to me

No, but he quoted me, leaving me with the impression that he was talking to me. I didn't know what the hell the dane was about.

WRX19
10-10-2005, 02:25 AM
I knew that VandyS4 would be the first to post on this one :biglaughc

Schneller Bayer
10-10-2005, 03:40 AM
I can see what you are arguing about a 280whp s4 not pulling onan e46 m3 but also compare the torque of the two cars. An s4with 280whp has more then 280wtq, and i know that an e46 m3 has nowhere near the same torque, also how is AWD going to hurt the s4 on the highway if it already has 280whp, awd isnt going to take away extra power just because they are on the highway now.

I was thinking crank hp, my bad, and so i factored in the extra drivetrain loss, given that the awd launch advantage is lost from a roll.

VandyS4
10-10-2005, 11:13 AM
I knew that VandyS4 would be the first to post on this one :biglaughc

And how did you know that?

oldM3r
10-10-2005, 11:20 AM
um if he heard a bov, it is not an s4, they have diverter valves and make no noise

redfoot
10-10-2005, 11:33 AM
um if he heard a bov, it is not an s4, they have diverter valves and make no noise
Immpossible to to put one on???
Really, I don't know.

PathosRx
10-10-2005, 11:50 AM
um if he heard a bov, it is not an s4, they have diverter valves and make no noise

the blow off valve sound can also be made with diverter valves with certain aftermarket intakes on the b5 s4 ... trust me i have seen and heard a setup that does this.

WRX19
10-10-2005, 12:10 PM
And how did you know that?


Because you are always one of the firsts whenever there is an Audi vs. BMW race...let alone an S4. You are the one who straightens out all of us bimmer guys on what's up with the Audis. :buttrock

Armo95
10-10-2005, 12:17 PM
Because you are always one of the firsts whenever there is an Audi vs. BMW race...let alone an S4. You are the one who straightens out all of us bimmer guys on what's up with the Audis. :buttrock

Man, do I miss my R1 :(

http://image.mypicgallery.com/rxxx7/2001-0720-051955aa_large.jpg

With my previous 95 M3:
http://image.mypicgallery.com/rx7111/2001-0720-051917aa_large.jpg

http://image.mypicgallery.com/rx7111/2001-0720-050600aa_large.jpg

WRX19
10-10-2005, 01:46 PM
the 7 looks tidy.

It's ok though because you have an avus M5!

giterdone
10-10-2005, 02:04 PM
armo you have a R1 also?!?!?!? Jesus, I love your past line of cars. I would've made the 95 m3 a 96+ but I guess everybody isn't perfect. :D

Armo95
10-10-2005, 05:52 PM
armo you have a R1 also?!?!?!? Jesus, I love your past line of cars. I would've made the 95 m3 a 96+ but I guess everybody isn't perfect. :D

Yea, she's long gone, though ... the guy above brought back some memories.

I would've loved to have kept them all ... that'd be Heaven + 1.

oldM3r
10-10-2005, 06:12 PM
the blow off valve sound can also be made with diverter valves with certain aftermarket intakes on the b5 s4 ... trust me i have seen and heard a setup that does this.

this is news to me and I owned an s4 with aftermarket valves, the s4 uses a bypass valve that does not vent into the atmosphere, when I owned the car there were several failed attempts to change the bypass to a blow off, there is a major difference in programing the computer that needs to be done for a sound effect.

Is it possible yes is it probable no.

I too miss my rx7 and the ubsurdly loud Greddy BOV it had, not to mention the acceleration, still would kick my modded m5 ass to well north of 100 mph.


http://www.awe-tuning.com/pages/shared/part_detail.cfm?PMaI=1&PMoI=4&PEI=6&PP=s4_27t_drivetrain.cfm&PPT=Drivetrain&IL=BaileyValve

see how the s4 deals with off throttle boost.

WRX19
10-10-2005, 06:36 PM
does this mean I have to get an E39 M5 now?? Two guys who used to have 7's now in M5's. Damn! I can't do that, it's too expensive :stickoutt

Armo95
10-10-2005, 06:45 PM
does this mean I have to get an E39 M5 now?? Two guys who used to have 7's now in M5's. Damn! I can't do that, it's too expensive :stickoutt

Basically :)

m3racer36
10-10-2005, 07:20 PM
Ill take a 95 m3 over a 96+ anyday

awahl63
10-10-2005, 07:31 PM
So you hang with E46 m3s?
uh oh

giterdone
10-10-2005, 07:39 PM
Ill take a 95 m3 over a 96+ anyday
not i said the duck.