View Full Version : e46 vs e55 who would win.


BimmerMan20
09-10-2004, 02:38 PM
I have a quick question is some of you peeps can help me out here. I have a 03 e46 M3 and a friend of mine has a 02 e55 amg mercedes. He was saying he could waste me but and i told him no way. I know he has about 17 more hp then me but his car is also a 4 door which weights a lot. My knowledge about the older e55 is not that great and i do not know to much about them. What do you people think.

s54gasm
09-10-2004, 02:48 PM
im pretty sure you would get owned on the highway, but i think you have the advantage 0-60 and through the corners. his car is fast but it handles worse than an E38 7 series.

BimmerMan20
09-10-2004, 02:49 PM
im pretty sure you would get owned on the highway, but i think you have the advantage 0-60 and through the corners. his car is fast but it handles worse than an E38 7 series.

How would I get owned so bad when he has 17 more Hp but the car weights i think about 3800lbs.

s54gasm
09-10-2004, 02:51 PM
V8. boat loads or torque.

i could be wrong, but i think thats how it would turn out. only one way to be sure though.

BimmerMan20
09-10-2004, 03:04 PM
Yah I know me and him have been meaning to sit down for a while now. Its definelty going to be a highway run. I just thought maybe somebody on here had some run in with this car. If he had the new one forget he would waste me but he has the older body style and a slower and also heavier.

s54gasm
09-10-2004, 03:17 PM
i beat a cl500 with my M3, but this is an AMG, so i really dont know

BimmerMan20
09-10-2004, 03:20 PM
i beat a cl500 with my M3, but this is an AMG, so i really dont know

The cl500 is up there hp wise as well. Yah this is a amg but it only has 350 hp and the car weights about 3800lbs.

PrinceE30
09-10-2004, 03:46 PM
KEVLAR has worked against an E55 on the road and like someone above said, on the straits it's all AMG power. But in the curves, the M3 will own it.

BEST MOTORing has a video that has the E55 and a CSL together and the E55 ends up last in the race.

-Prince

jrlvwjet
09-10-2004, 04:10 PM
Well, if you have enough room on the freeway, get a good draft on him, then pullout and sling shot passed him. Once you get a car length, get on your brakes to let him know it's over, otherwise his larger motor and hp will take over eventually and he'll pass you.

Works on Z06s! :buttrock

BimmerMan20
09-10-2004, 04:10 PM
KEVLAR has worked against an E55 on the road and like someone above said, on the straits it's all AMG power. But in the curves, the M3 will own it.

BEST MOTORing has a video that has the E55 and a CSL together and the E55 ends up last in the race.

-Prince

Yah i know in the turns they are horrible but we are thinking about a highway run.

Beavis
09-10-2004, 05:57 PM
I raced an 04 E55, he put several car lengths on me from 70 to 130.
If the 02 E55 is the older motor (non supercharged) I think you should be able to beat him :buttrock

Vailm3
09-10-2004, 11:18 PM
The 02 and older E55's have 361 horses and 391 Foot lbs. at higher speed 60+ he would pull on you all day :(

Franchise
09-11-2004, 12:22 AM
http://car-stats.com/stats/default.aspx

jrlvwjet
09-11-2004, 11:31 AM
Hey Franchise, by any chance you drive a lowered silver E46 M3 with the OEM 19s? I work in Concord, and I drive a lowered (PSS9s) Mystic Blue M3. I don't see too many E46 M3s, let alone modified ones. Just thought I'd say hello!

Franchise
09-11-2004, 04:17 PM
Hey Franchise, by any chance you drive a lowered silver E46 M3 with the OEM 19s? I work in Concord, and I drive a lowered (PSS9s) Mystic Blue M3. I don't see too many E46 M3s, let alone modified ones. Just thought I'd say hello!

i wish :(

Yeti
09-11-2004, 05:24 PM
winning isnt everything. He still has to sleep at night knowing that he doesnt have an M3, instead he has a family sedan

BimmerMan20
09-13-2004, 10:19 AM
I raced an 04 E55, he put several car lengths on me from 70 to 130.
If the 02 E55 is the older motor (non supercharged) I think you should be able to beat him :buttrock

Yah he has the non supercharged 349hp one. If it was the new one forget it but its the older big heavy one.

BimmerMan20
09-13-2004, 10:20 AM
winning isnt everything. He still has to sleep at night knowing that he doesnt have an M3, instead he has a family sedan

hahahahhaha thats awesome

332 RustBucket
09-13-2004, 10:51 AM
I raced an 04 E55, he put several car lengths on me from 70 to 130.



:lol several, man it was a BOAT LOAD!!! :evil2

omszz
09-14-2004, 08:17 PM
Even if the E55 can take M3 in straight line, let him drive your M3 - I'm sure he'll be jealous from then on.

332 RustBucket
09-14-2004, 10:46 PM
Even if the E55 can take M3 in straight line, let him drive your M3 - I'm sure he'll be jealous from then on.

People don't buy the e55 cause it can beat a M3 in the straight line or in the curves. Different buyer IMO.

maxse01
09-15-2004, 06:37 PM
People don't buy the e55 cause it can beat a M3 in the straight line or in the curves. Different buyer IMO.


Exactly. I think people know when they buy one that they have a car that is fast as hell, quite and comfortable. That to me is why to buy a merc. I wouldn't because 1. i love my M3 and 2. i prefer to DRIVE, not be propelled. :D