View Full Version : Contest [#31] Voting
Mister X 05-12-2008, 03:49 PM 1. Voting is open to everyone and will last for 7 days.
2. Voting for yourself is not allowed, nor is the creation of new members to vote for yourself.
3. When you post your votes, please add some "constructive" comments. We all can learn from this I'm sure.
4. Everyone who wants to vote will pick and post their top 4 entries (they cannot vote for themselves). Then the 10 points will be distributed as follows..
1st place gets 4 points
2nd place gets 3 points
3rd place gets 2 points
4th place gets 1 point
This is how to post your VOTE
4pts for ________- then add comments here.
3pts for ________- then add comments here.
2pts for ________- then add comments here.
1pt for ________- then add comments here.
Lots of solid entries. I decided to throw mine in since it is obvious I didn't borrow ideas from anyone else :)
Good luck to everyone.
Images in next post.
Mister X 05-12-2008, 03:53 PM [1]
http://www.sbeuro.com/domhost/contest/1.jpg
[2]
http://www.sbeuro.com/domhost/contest/2.jpg
[3]
http://www.sbeuro.com/domhost/contest/3.jpg
[4]
http://www.sbeuro.com/domhost/contest/4.jpg
[5]
http://www.sbeuro.com/domhost/contest/5.jpg
[6]
http://www.sbeuro.com/domhost/contest/6.jpg
[7]
http://www.sbeuro.com/domhost/contest/7.jpg
[8]
http://www.sbeuro.com/domhost/contest/8.jpg
StarReaver 05-12-2008, 04:08 PM 4pts for #6 - Excellent job on the lighting and reflections.
3pts for #3 - Very clean! Nice 2-door conversion.
2pts for #4 - I REALLY like the Aston tails and look, but the reflections seem a bit off.
1pt for #1 - Nice and aggressive! But the lines look a bit blurred and the rear wheel bugs me a bit.
MSFIT 05-12-2008, 05:25 PM 4pts for 3 - very good chop
3pts for 6 - horrible wheel selection, everything else is good
2pts for 5 - bad color, hood is kinda funky lookin near windshield, rim chop was bad(use the circle selection and then transform selection), front bumper not clean after the stretching of it you did.
1pt for 4 - kkinda clean chop, colors are a little off, wheel selection again sux
MSFIT 05-12-2008, 05:25 PM can u post orig pic?
teh_activ 05-12-2008, 05:37 PM 4-#3
3-#4
2-#6
1-#7
nice job everyone!
i didnt hav PS so i couldnt participate but next time i will [hopefully]
teh_activ 05-12-2008, 05:38 PM if BMW ever made #3 id buy it :drool great chop
Artista 05-12-2008, 09:41 PM 4 for #6
3 for #2
2 for #3
1 for #5
zeplin0325 05-13-2008, 07:15 AM 4pts - #6 This is one of the most impressive chops I've seen, totally turned the image upside down, very clean chop... I very likey...!!!
3pts - #7 Beautiful chop as well... Nice lines, reflections are very well done...
2pts - #3 Nice simple chop... Love the rear end...
1pt - #2 Had to vote for myself... :D
Shucks, no one likes Lightning Mcqueen?
matt535 05-13-2008, 10:34 AM 4 pts #6 - fucking great chop. everything about it.
3 pts #7 - quality of the work is very high. good stuff
2 pts #5 - fuck of audi Q7
1 pt #2 - rock the fuck on lightning mcqueen
AdotOdot4 05-13-2008, 10:34 AM 4 points for #6 I gotta give you props for making those wheels work.
3 points for #7 Nice vert conversion. Only comment is that passenger side doesn't seem to have a windshield.
2 points for #4 Clean chop.
1 point for #2 :rofl
LupinIII 05-13-2008, 04:50 PM 3pts for 4 - i'm a sucker for the rear and of an aston, and you tacked it onto the CS pretty well, the color match is great. i guess the little bits that need some work are that the reflections from the body don't continue onto the bumper (very difficult to do) and the front rims seems flat (the perspective seems off). Great job!
3pts for 5 - clean wagon/coupe thing transformation (call it a hatchback?). gets a little messy by the window where you had to extend it and such, but overall not bad. paint is a little flat though, the reflections lost contrast in the color change.
2pts for 2 - I like the cars transformations. pretty well done too, and the rims fit well. I would have smashed the grill to be really short so i could fit a bigger, cartoonier mouth, but that's just me.
2pts for 1 - clean white conversion, and i like the style. as said before the rear rim seems flat (not the correct perspective), and it seems strange to use a different donor pic from those provided.
comments for other chops:
3- nice chop, i'm just not very keen on side chops. the front vent thing looks odd, and the kink wasn't fully erased. the two door conversion is really clean though, and otherwise it's a great chop.
6- not much i can say, front drivers side vent looks a little off tho.
7-nice convertible, good job finding a side that fit the angle. only problem though is that the bg thru the windscreen is different saturations and contrasts between either side of the driver's seat. I like the work with the front bumper too.
8-front bumper is low quality and pixelated, and doesn't fit perspective. also the paint is oversaturated and the decals don't match paint reflections. a valorous effort, but needs help. I suggests google searching photoshop tutorials for car chopping, there's some good stuff on the net. :)
sisomphonE 05-13-2008, 07:14 PM 7
sisomphonE 05-13-2008, 07:18 PM 2pts for #7
RJ 325is 05-13-2008, 07:25 PM 4 - #7 Sickness Estroil blue
3 - #3 clean
2 - #6 wtf batmobile?
1 - #4 sarite
Bingo 05-14-2008, 02:11 AM 4pts for #3 - I'd buy that in a heartbeat. Next M Coupe anyone?
3pts for #6 - Clean shop, lighting looks good.
2pts for #7 - I guess I like the color.
1pt for #4 - I like the Aston rear but the color looks funny.
JustinE36M3 05-14-2008, 03:21 PM 6
MSFIT 05-14-2008, 03:33 PM its a close race between 3 and 6 it looks like
straight6pwr 05-16-2008, 03:28 PM 4pts for #4 lolz
3pts for #7
2pts for #1
1pt for #2
Rakshas 05-16-2008, 07:50 PM 4 pts for 6- I'd buy that car in a heartbeat, love the Lambo cues
3 pts for 3- Gorgeous except for front bumper and sideskirt selection
2 pts for 1
1 pt for 4
raceMpower95 05-18-2008, 11:11 AM DUDE!? What the hell where is mine? I sent it in like two weeks early!
Edit: I guess it's pointless now but whatever. Here it was. If you guys want to re-vote, feel free.
http://www.blankmediagroup.com/Pictures/Dave/bfc/bfc_concept_cs_800.jpg
Mister X 05-18-2008, 12:19 PM DUDE!? What the hell where is mine? I sent it in like two weeks early!
Edit: I guess it's pointless now but whatever. Here it was. If you guys want to re-vote, feel free.
http://www.blankmediagroup.com/Pictures/Dave/bfc/bfc_concept_cs_800.jpg
I don't have an email from you.
raceMpower95 05-18-2008, 08:52 PM I don't have an email from you.
I PM'ed it to you like two days after the contest started.
Mister X 05-18-2008, 09:28 PM I PM'ed it to you like two days after the contest started.
I responded asking you to email it to me.
straight6pwr 05-19-2008, 02:44 PM I responded asking you to email it to me.
lame move not posting it anyways.
Mister X 05-19-2008, 07:08 PM I'll post which entries belong to who tonight.
lame move not posting it anyways.
I didn't do it on purpose, I have deleted my pms since then and just assumed he emailed it, I didn't look at the photo when he messaged it to me so I didn't realize it was missing.
I don't feel bad though, I made the email account so that I could keep the entries organized, if he is too retarded to submit it properly, even after being reminded, and then bitch about not being entered, I'm happy he wasn't entered in the contest.
MSFIT 05-20-2008, 05:35 PM so is the voting over now? who won?
Mister X 05-20-2008, 06:31 PM Here is what belongs to who.
1- matt535
2- zeplin0325
3- straight6pwr
4- Me
5- Motentra
6- LupinIII
7- NorcalBMW
8- Gatsby740iL
Gatsby740il 05-21-2008, 12:12 AM Yep.. I'm Client #8... I'd like to Congratulate my fellow Artists and PSDers on a Hell Of A Job! I really took the "Rules" the wrong way when working on my pic. I thought THAT was the pic we had to work with (ie: couldn't change background, etc etc..) and had to just do with it what we could.
My entry also appeared smaller (and blurry-not like my Original) than the others... but it's all good. When it came down to it... Everyone really did an A1 job and I'm proud to have been in such good company! That's, truthfully, why I didn't Pitch-A-Bitch ever during the 'Voting'... I didn't want to come across as being sour at all... because like I said... I'm happy to have been in a contest with such fine artists! (Atleast 1 Positive Vote would have been nice-But Such Is Life!) And as I said... somehow my photo (as can be seen) didn't arrive the way I thought I had sent it (resulting in a blurry, pixelated front end, etc..) and that, too, was my own fault!:)
I had thought about pulling my entry (especially after the comment that "I" should look up Photoshop tutorials online!). But I, HONESTLY, DO appreciate the criticism and, as with everything else I work for or on, I'll learn from this and move on.
Thanks To Mister X for the contest(!), my ability to participate, and to everyone who Voted! And, Once Again, To My Fellow Artists.... Congrats on some AMAZING work!
Cheers!
-Gatsby740iL :cool
LupinIII 05-21-2008, 08:10 AM lame move not posting it anyways.
having hosted a few, i really just check emails when i post my address and specifically say email them. i'm not going to search all means of contact for entries, and when it comes time to post up the thread, you really just pay attention to the means that you told people to use (because it's what you expect)
i'll see if i can tally votes later if no one else does it, great entries everyone! sorry gatsby that yours didn't get points, we'll have to look at the .psd and work on it a bit
Gatsby740il 05-21-2008, 04:39 PM Thanks, Lupin! As I said... I take full responsibility... I may very well have sent the wrong file as I had a few saved as "Works In Progress" and my finished entry.. so it could have been an upload error on my part. I'm not sure why it posted so small or pixelated.. but, again, it's no big deal. Plus.. IMO.. some of the others really worked hard (different backgrounds, creating a Coupe--which I didn't think we could do and I should have asked for clarity)... and their pictures show the hard work/talent!
Again.. Thanks To Everyone and Congrats on some Fine Work!
-Gatsby :cool
straight6pwr 05-21-2008, 06:09 PM nice photoshop work lupinIII, but i hope you dont think that styling is acceptable. :eyecrazy
Mister X 05-21-2008, 06:33 PM Thanks, Lupin! As I said... I take full responsibility... I may very well have sent the wrong file as I had a few saved as "Works In Progress" and my finished entry.. so it could have been an upload error on my part. I'm not sure why it posted so small or pixelated.. but, again, it's no big deal. Plus.. IMO.. some of the others really worked hard (different backgrounds, creating a Coupe--which I didn't think we could do and I should have asked for clarity)... and their pictures show the hard work/talent!
Again.. Thanks To Everyone and Congrats on some Fine Work!
-Gatsby :cool
I just checked, because I was worried I might have messed it up, but it appears you did send the wrong one, it looks the same in the email as it does in the thread :(
MSFIT 05-21-2008, 07:29 PM so 3 won?
lol
it should, its the only one i would buy
byrdcall 05-21-2008, 08:26 PM #3 is good looking
Gatsby740il 05-21-2008, 11:52 PM I just checked, because I was worried I might have messed it up, but it appears you did send the wrong one, it looks the same in the email as it does in the thread :(
Yeah.. That's what I was affraid of. And, unfortunately, I had no idea until it was posted.. and there wasn't anything I could do then without anyone thinking I saw the entries and wanted to change mine. I had worked for a few days on it and I think I just got it mixed up with one of the others I had saved in .jpeg to try 'em out! It's ok though... I'm looking forward to the next contest!
Thanks Again, Mister X, for runnin' a 'Good Show'! :cool
LupinIII 05-22-2008, 11:53 PM nice photoshop work lupinIII, but i hope you dont think that styling is acceptable. :eyecrazy
haha thanks, i knew the wheels wouldn't be for everyone, but i liked the M1 look... otherwise i quite accept my styling :(
i'll have to add up points to see who won, looked close between mine and 3
zeplin0325 05-25-2008, 11:41 PM So.......... Who won?
I'm basically asking as he/she will be responsible for Contest #32... Which as of the current moment I have time for... :D
LupinIII 05-28-2008, 02:23 AM http://img134.imageshack.us/img134/4627/contest31uh8.jpg
I'm fairly certain i entered the data correctly, but if anyone sees something off please tell me.
So i don't mind hosting the next contest, but I've done a good share and might be busy in the coming weeks as school is approaching finals, so if straight6pwr would like to host that would be totally fine by me
Mister X 05-28-2008, 03:00 AM Good job everyone
LupinIII 05-28-2008, 09:37 PM any ideas for the next contest? I was thinking of trying it again where i give a series of bmw and you pick a base and chop off that.
or we can do e92 M3's...
Mister X 05-29-2008, 12:11 AM I like the series idea.
matt535 05-29-2008, 12:19 AM i like the E92 M3 idea
matt535 05-29-2008, 12:19 AM but i'm easy.
just ask your mum
:shifty
zeplin0325 05-29-2008, 03:47 AM any ideas for the next contest? I was thinking of trying it again where i give a series of bmw and you pick a base and chop off that.
or we can do e92 M3's...
I'd choose the e92 M3, but that's just me... Letting us pick our own base would be a bit harder to judge, IMHO...
Gatsby740il 05-29-2008, 08:03 AM So.......... Who won?
I'm basically asking as he/she will be responsible for Contest #32... Which as of the current moment I have time for... :D
Me Too.. especially since I sent the wrong entry this time around! :rolleyes
Ready and Waiting!
-Gatsby :cool
Gatsby740il 05-29-2008, 08:05 AM http://img134.imageshack.us/img134/4627/contest31uh8.jpg
How Humiliating! :(
Nah.. Congrats (Again) Everyone! Great Work! Let's do it again...
zeplin0325 05-30-2008, 10:39 PM How Humiliating! :(
Nah.. Congrats (Again) Everyone! Great Work! Let's do it again...
Don't worry about it... I've been averaging third from last ever since my first contest, and I'm still here... It's the fun of it that counts... :D
|
|